Our Team

News

Prevention Is Better Than Cure: Getting Your Multi-Neighbourhood Provider Structure Right

Most GP practices are partnerships, so company law can feel like unfamiliar territory. Companies come with their own built-in rules and checks and balances, and when these aren’t well understood, proposed multi-neighbourhood provider structures can end up over-engineered, incompatible with company law, or both.

Broadly, there are four types of company to choose from: a private company limited by shares or by guarantee, or a community interest company (CIC) limited by shares or by guarantee. A company’s owners are its members (shareholders or guarantors, depending on the type). Unless I say otherwise, what follows applies to all four.

First, what you don’t need to worry about

The best place to start is with everything a company’s constitution doesn’t need to cover, because the law already covers it for you.

The Companies Act 2006: the big rulebook

The Companies Act 2006 has over 1,300 sections; the Partnership Act 1890 has just 50. Some of the Act’s rules can be tailored, but most can’t. It covers, among other things:

  • changing the constitution
  • directors’ powers, duties, appointment and removal
  • members’ rights and decision-making
  • record-keeping, annual accounts and Companies House filings
  • granting security and dissolving the company
  • for companies limited by shares, issuing shares and paying out profits.

Each area has its own detail too. Conflicts of interest, for example, are governed by the Act and by more than 160 years of case law.

So, when you’re designing a constitution, some of these areas never need thinking about, some always do, and some only matter in certain cases.

Model Articles: the tried and tested default

On top of the Act, every company has Articles of Association. People often think of the Articles as the constitution, but they’re really just the part you can change.

If a company doesn’t adopt its own Articles, it automatically gets the government’s Model Articles. The version for a private company limited by shares has just 53 sections, covering directors’ decision-making, board meetings, conflicts, appointing, removing and paying directors, members’ voting, and directors’ indemnities and insurance. Because they’re so well established and stable, my advice is to change them as little as possible, and only where it’s genuinely necessary or at least highly desirable.

So what do you actually need to decide?

With the Act and the Model Articles doing most of the heavy lifting, there’s surprisingly little left to decide: what rights the members have, who the members are, and who the directors are.

Members

Members get a vote, but that matters less than you might think. The most fundamental rule in company law is that members hand the running of the company over to the directors.

Directors run companies, members don’t.

That’s why shareholders have no personal liability, and guarantors’ liability is usually capped at £1. Members’ statutory decision-making rights are already in the Companies Act, so there’s no need to repeat them in the constitution.

One of those rights is to remove a director, but you can neutralise it by letting each member appoint its own director. Say your multi-neighbourhood provider has 7 members, each a PCN or single neighbourhood, and each can appoint its own director. You couldn’t stop 4 members voting to remove another member’s director. But removing a director is a lengthy and complicated process, and nobody would bother if they knew the appointing member could simply reappoint that person with a one-line email.

Members are sometimes given extra rights in a members’ or shareholders’ agreement. Tread carefully: if members effectively make the decisions, they risk being treated as ‘shadow directors’ and becoming personally liable. A veto over certain board decisions is usually a safer way to protect members without tying the directors’ hands.

In a company limited by shares, profits are split by shareholding by default. You can change this by giving each shareholder a different class of share allowing different dividends to be declared. A shareholders’ agreement would usually link these to list size.

Who the members should be depends on local geography: usually GP practices or PCNs/single neighbourhoods, sometimes tailored to include a strong GP Federation.

Directors

Getting the board right is essential, and more art than science. You need an appointment process that lets members feel represented without getting in the way of the board’s ability to manage. There’s no one-size-fits-all answer here: so much depends on the primary care landscape, and it usually needs deciding alongside membership.

Two points are key: only directors can make management decisions, and all directors are responsible for all of the company’s decisions. That’s why structures where separate committees run separate districts don’t work.

Directors can set up advisory committees and delegate decision-making (but not responsibility), and individual directors will naturally specialise. But the board still decides collectively, one vote per director, so it’s best to leave delegation to the directors rather than hard-wiring it into the constitution.

The bottom line

This is a whistle-stop tour, not a definitive guide. Company law is arguably as complex as, say, cardiology, and with constitutions the devil really is in the detail.

It’s tempting to sketch out a structure yourself, but backtracking later can be awkward, especially once others are on board. Problems are quicker and cheaper to fix the earlier they’re spotted, so involving lawyers from the start gets the best value from your legal spend. As with most things, prevention is better than cure.

If you’re in the early stages and would like to talk through the options or sense-check an idea, we’re always happy to have an informal conversation. Get in touch here!

By Sarah Cook and Nigel Kotani

Share